The Cab Fare Was Only $50,000…It Was The $20,000 Tip

Old habits die hard, and I can’t help but keep up with the law firm world.  Today I read about a partner of a major law firm who submitted $120K in false expense reports over 5 years; $69K on fraudulent taxi cab receipts alone.  Even for a big tipper, that’s a lot of cab fare.


The partner said he didn’t do it for personal gain, he was just too busy on important client work to try to deal with the firm’s complicated expense reporting procedures.  I have no problem believing that the partner thought he was too busy to deal with procedures that he thought were too complicated.

The story took me right back to my days of law firm accounting, so I took a couple of aspirin.  This scenario strikes fear in the heart of every accounting manager, because all firms have very busy, very important partners who think they should be exempt from the pesky and complicated internal controls.  The problem is that while large law firms now operate like Corporate America, they are not publicly held.  Their shareholders have names and faces and corner offices, and hover in your doorway asking WTF, because they own the place.

In my prior life a partner like this would come to me on occasion and express his or her feelings about my department and procedures.  I would say “If someone in the firm embezzled $282,346.73 in petty cash based on ‘lost’ taxi receipts, who is the first person you would blame for not minding the shop?”  Sometimes this resulted in a partner asking if I was accusing him of being a thief, but most of them understood what I was trying to say.

Even if I wanted to cut someone a break, there were layers of bureaucracy above me. At one of my firms, the woman who was ultimately responsible for policing expense reports was nothing short of legendary.  She invented the word “scrutiny.”  She was 95 pounds of suspicion, wise cracks and English as a second language.  She was also smart and hilarious and I mostly adored her.  Fortunately she was in an office thousands of miles away, because in person every day would have been a bit much.

When we did get together in person for meetings and such, my colleagues and I would pour appletinis down her throat and beg her to tell us stories of how she terrorized her colleagues in her previous career.  Although Susie’s English was decent, she sometimes got things confused.  For example, when she’d tell us stories she would conclude with “That’s all bridges under water now.”  Sometimes I would use that very phrase when the CFO fussed at me on a conference call, and he would clear his throat and move on to the next item on the agenda.

Sans appletinis, it was not unusual for me to answer my phone and hear “WHAT YOU THINK YOU DOING?” in a rather unpleasant screech.  I would say “Hey Susie, how are you?”  I would put the phone down while she screamed some more, and then I would tell her I had to run but would get back to her soon.  I had a mole in her office who would tell me the minute Susie left her desk, and I would call and leave a voice mail saying I was sorry I missed her.  It wasn’t perfect, but it worked in my little world.

Susie once harassed an associate so much about his receipt timeline (she was like a detective) that he started taking pictures of himself in front of the hotel or a major city landmark, holding up a paper with that day’s date, and attached them to his receipts.  This is 110% true; I couldn’t make this stuff up.

Anyway, when I read about this fraudulent receipt situation, I thought about Susie and it made me smile.  Not under her watch my friend…not under her watch.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to The Cab Fare Was Only $50,000…It Was The $20,000 Tip

  1. mimijk says:

    Oh the hard-knock life of a partner suffused with an abundance of self-importance. If only the rest of us would just understand. Damn those internal controls – until of course someone is actually embezzling. How familiar this all seems…and I’m two years removed!! I guess I’m still de-toxing…

    • Jill Foer Hirsch says:

      I guess my recovery isn’t going so well because I’m still checking out the AmLaw highlights every day…and I’ve been known to check out Above the Law once a week or so. It’s a little bit like a train wreck-can’t help but look?

  2. Kate says:

    We have recently had some major embezzlements at the local government level that went on for years. One was close to a million $$ over about 10 years from water/sewer receipts. As a former corporate employee where there were massive checks and balances I was stunned that this could happen. I once worked with a departmental Suzie and hated every minute of it. You could have all the right paperwork and you would still get hassled. Then I moved to another department and wiz bam my expenses were accepted no problem!

    • Kate says:

      BTW I love the pictures idea. Wish I would have thought of that!

      • Jill Foer Hirsch says:

        I had counterparts in 20+ other offices–I immediately let them all know about my associate’s ingenuity. Then I picked up a mocha latte and delivered it to his office. Adorable.

    • Jill Foer Hirsch says:

      It’s really not that hard to embezzle-just stupid. There’s no way this guy did it for the money though. He for sure makes at least a couple million a year; I believe he thought he was too busy to be bothered with receipts. I used to eat guys like this for breakfast. This is why HR seemed like my natural career progression!

  3. Abbe says:

    This is priceless!

Comments are closed.